Outplayed

Early in 2024, a finance clerk at the engineering firm Arup joined a video call with his chief financial officer and six senior colleagues. All of them were deepfakes. He transferred $25 million.

That is what the dead internet theory has become. What began as a claim about an internet polluted with obvious junk now describes something more serious: an internet where AI-driven users vastly outnumber humans and can convincingly impersonate them. Slopaganda, mass-produced AI content designed to capture attention, arrived first. In 2025, bots generated more web traffic than humans. But the greater harm was never going to come from volume. It was always going to come from impersonation. And through impersonation, deception.

Phase one: volume-maxxing

Dead internet theory originated in a 2021 post on the Agora Road forum and reached a wider audience through The Atlantic later that year. It holds that most online activity is now generated by bots as a result of deliberate manipulation, and dates the internet’s “death” to around 2016.

In 2024, according to Imperva, automated traffic overtook human activity, and by 2025 bots made up 53% of all internet traffic.

The effects are most visible on social platforms. In 2024 researchers at the Stanford Internet Observatory documented Facebook pages using AI-generated images, the best known being “Shrimp Jesus”, to build audiences for spam and scams. Facebook showed the images to users who did not follow the pages, and many commenters appeared not to realise the images were synthetic. In April 2024 Elon Musk said that any X account caught “engagement farming” would be “suspended and traced to source”.

Search engines struggled to contain the deluge. A year-long study by researchers at Leipzig University and Bauhaus-Universität Weimar tracked 7,392 product-review queries on Google, Bing and DuckDuckGo. It found that all three were losing ground to search-optimised spam and that ranking updates produced only temporary improvements. In March 2024 Google said its core update would cut low-quality, unoriginal content in results by 40%, and it later reported a 45% reduction.

The decline in the quality of social media feeds has led many users to step back from social platforms. In the UK, Ofcom’s 2026 Adults’ Media Use and Attitudes report found that the share of adult social media users who post, share or comment fell from 61% in 2024 to 49%.

Most of this material fits the philosopher Harry Frankfurt’s definition of bullshit, which is speech produced without regard for whether it is true. In On Bullshit (2005), Frankfurt argued that bullshit is “a greater enemy of the truth than lies are”, because the liar must know the truth in order to hide it, while the bullshitter is indifferent to it. The producers of volume-maxxing content were optimising for engagement and had no interest in accuracy.

The limits of volume

Mass-produced content was easy to detect, but it nonetheless contaminated the data used to train future AI models. In January 2025 Elon Musk said that the “cumulative sum of human knowledge” had been exhausted in AI training, leaving developers more reliant on synthetic data. Researchers at Rice University found that generative models trained repeatedly on their own output lose quality or diversity within a few generations, a condition they called Model Autophagy Disorder (MAD). A 2024 paper in Nature, by a team including researchers at Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial College London and Edinburgh, found the same effect in language models and called it “model collapse”.

Later work found that collapse can be avoided when synthetic data is added to real data instead of replacing it. Ultimately, model collapse gave AI labs a reason to curate training data with greater care. Volume was a problem the industry could see and begin to manage. The harder problem became detecting AI good enough to be taken for a real person.

Phase two: impersonation

AI agents are now outpacing us on speed, volume and, more quietly, learning to pass as human. Fake faces most of us can no longer tell apart from real ones. AI-driven social media accounts that go months without being spotted. Humans on the web are being outplayed, by systems trained on everything we have ever written.

In September 2025 Sam Altman, chief executive of OpenAI, posted that he “never took the dead internet theory that seriously” but that there now seemed to be “a lot of LLM-run twitter accounts”. Since 2022, controlled studies have gone beyond anecdote and shown AI performing at or above human level at the specific task of seeming human.

  • In a 2022 study in PNAS, Sophie Nightingale of Lancaster University and Hany Farid of the University of California, Berkeley found that participants could not reliably distinguish AI-generated faces from real ones, and rated the synthetic faces 7.7% more trustworthy on average. The images were produced with StyleGAN2, which later image models have surpassed.
  • In a 2025 three-party Turing test at UC San Diego, GPT-4.5 was judged to be the human 73% of the time when prompted to adopt a humanlike persona, more often than the real human participants, in conversations lasting five minutes. Without the persona prompt, its rate fell to 36%.
  • Between November 2024 and March 2025, researchers at the University of Zurich ran an unauthorised experiment on Reddit’s r/changemyview forum, in which AI-run accounts posted 1,783 comments and received 137 “deltas”, the forum’s marker that a commenter has changed someone’s view. The researchers reported that no user raised the possibility that the comments were AI-generated. The study was ethically contested and the accounts were banned.

The Zurich accounts were run by academics working under ethical review; operators without those constraints, using later models, are likely to go undetected for longer.

Search ranking and content moderation were built to sort and remove content. Neither was designed to establish whether the person on the other side of a conversation is real.

Warnings from the frontier

Egregious uses the term superhuman deception for this capability, meaning AI that, in specific tests, is better than people at appearing human or trustworthy.

“If it gets to be much smarter than us, it will be very good at manipulation because it will have learned that from us. And there are very few examples of a more intelligent thing being controlled by a less intelligent thing.”

Geoffrey Hinton, speaking to CNN, May 2023

Several researchers who have left frontier AI companies have published their reasons. Most raised concerns broader than deception, but two addressed it directly. Zoë Hitzig, who left OpenAI in February 2026 as it began testing advertising in ChatGPT, warned that an advertising model gives the company incentives to manipulate its users. David Robinson, who led the safety reports for OpenAI’s major launches, resigned in late September 2026. He wrote that the company’s culture was “broken” and, according to reporting of his essay, warned that more capable systems could evade safety tests. Other departures raised wider concerns about safety culture and the pace of development, including Jan Leike from OpenAI in 2024, and Mrinank Sharma and the British researcher Jacob Coxon from Anthropic in 2026.

State actors

Russia, China and Iran are now using AI tools to “turbocharge” disinformation, according to people familiar with US intelligence. The People’s Liberation Army established an Information Support Force in April 2024 as a new strategic branch. Its stated role is to coordinate the PLA’s network information systems. Analysts at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute assess that its remit also covers offensive disinformation.

Russia has adapted its methods to AI systems directly. In March 2025 NewsGuard found that ten leading chatbots repeated false narratives from the Moscow-based Pravda network about a third of the time, across a test set of 15 narratives. The network republishes Russian state media and pro-Kremlin material across around 150 sites, and the American Sunlight Project assessed that it was probably designed to reach AI models more than human readers, a tactic it called “LLM grooming”. As a result, people who ask a chatbot for an answer can receive Kremlin narratives without ever visiting a Kremlin-linked site.

On 22 September 2026, in his first address to the UN General Assembly, the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, announced a National Centre for Information Defence to “detect, attribute and disrupt” hostile state information attacks. He said the Kremlin spends around £1.3 billion a year on manipulating information. Sophie Williams-Dunning of RUSI called it a welcome, if overdue, step. To succeed, the centre will need to detect impersonation as well as false content.

Consequences

The move from volume-maxxing AI slop to sophisticated impersonation changes what it means to defend. Ranking and moderation were designed for a problem of content, where the material itself gives the fake away. They do little when the content itself looks ordinary and the identity behind it is a fake.

An effective response depends on detecting deception and attributing it to those responsible. That is the remit the UK has given the National Centre for Information Defence, and it is the capability that hostile states’ use of AI makes necessary.

Frequently asked questions

What is the dead internet theory?

The dead internet theory is the claim that most online content and activity now comes from bots and AI rather than people. It originated in a 2021 forum post and says the internet “died” in about 2016.

Is the dead internet theory true?

Bots generated 53% of internet traffic in 2025, according to Thales, and generative AI has made fake text and imagery cheap to produce. The more recent concern is the quality and quantity of AI impersonation, which can now pass as human.

What is superhuman deception?

Superhuman deception is the ability for frontier AI models to impersonate humans in order to earn and exploit their trust. Typically deployed by scammers and fraudsters, superhuman deception is also used by foreign state actors such as Russia, China and Iran, to turbocharge disinformation campaigns.

What percentage of the internet is bots?

Just over half of internet traffic. The 2026 Bad Bot Report from Thales found that bots made up 53% of all internet traffic in 2025, and that malicious bots alone accounted for 40%.

What is model collapse?

Model collapse is the loss of quality and diversity that occurs when AI systems are trained repeatedly on AI-generated material. Researchers at Rice University call it Model Autophagy Disorder, or MAD, by analogy with mad cow disease, and a 2024 study in Nature found the same effect in language models.